Monday, February 3, 2014

Book shaming is a joke…Right?

I have noticed a trend in the past few years among authors. It is the pastime of shaming readers, authors, and publishers for the types of books they enjoy. It permeates almost every genre. This is particularly true among the vanity press market. The last time I checked authors that write romance, erotica, romance, sci-fiction, fantasy, paranormal, horror, new adult, young adult, and the many other sub-categories all write under the larger umbrella of fiction. This means that the majority of what they write is not true. It is fantasy pure and simple. Some of it is well written and others books are well…not…so…much. However, the main issue at hand is that it is all make believe. It is not true. There is no need to distinguish between what is considered to be ‘intelligent’ fiction vs. ‘gutter’ fiction, because it is all….fiction. Most people view this genre as unintelligent anyway unless your book has been deemed worthy of being the great American novel. As fiction writers on the vanity market, your work is not being read in college classrooms, debated at conferences, and being recommended by the greatest thinkers of our time.

No, your work is being read while someone goes to the bathroom. Yup, I said it. Every day people read your work at every waking moment. It is probably frequently read while someone is on the toilet or bathing. Thank goodness for those folks. Otherwise, many of the lesser known authors with less than ten published titles would be known by well…no one. There would be no one to purchase, download, and blog about your books. This is why there is no need to book shame. I am sure that there is room in the bathroom library for your title as well.    

The funny thing about the publishing industry is always the authors. The culture could leave your head spinning. The shaming inside the industry is far worse than the almost nonexistent shaming by those that sit outside the industry. It becomes a game for authors that are losing sales to new authors. It is perfectly common for a nonfiction author to comment on a fiction author (even though they haven’t even read the person’s work). It is common for a romance author to comment on an erotic author’s work. It is common for a most authors that don’t even read the body of work in a genre to comment on another authors work.

The biggest joke includes the authors that are classified under the urban fiction market. In the past few years, there are authors taking to blogs, doing blog interviews, and even spending time influencing major review companies to trash other authors. It is possible the saddest thing anyone can witness. The worst thing is that every author, blogger, and publisher spending time trashing another person’s work has really missed the mark. In the end, it is about a greater picture of literacy not your individual book sales. Otherwise, you become no different than the authors that write books to further their brand via a ghost author or the self-proclaimed hustler/writers that ‘write to eat’. The fact of the matter is that an author can have a well written book, edited, and proofread. It doesn’t mean that the book is a decent read. The content of the book could be awful and not engaging to the reader. It happens all the time. Any book critic will tell you this is the case. There is a huge difference between a book critic and a book reviewer. Please learn the difference. I would never tell someone not to get caught up in syntax. However, I am one of the people in the industry that is concerned about where these conversations are going.

When did authors begin behaving like rappers? Why are well established authors starting beefs with new authors that are outselling them in the publishing market? In the end, it is about the book and reader, right? It is about the experience the reader walks away with after finishing a book. It really is best to let the reader decide what they want to read.     

Mistakes

It is as if people derive some pleasure from book shaming authors, readers, and publishers for doing what they love. It is a practice that doesn’t make any sense. The excuses are just a flimsy as a chiffon dress in the rain and border hypocrisy. For example, I read several postings via discussion boards on Facebook about authors that need editors. It was written by an author that I have on my shelf currently. I could literally take a red pen to this authors work and find at least fifty four mistakes in the first two chapters. This means that before you throw stones at another writers work that you should make sure that you are not living in a cheap, glass house.

Book covers

I have seen it all and it is sickening. Authors whether self-published or not are talking about the book covers of books. Really? Perhaps you should make sure that your own book cover actually matches the content you have inside the book. I have seen some of the worst book covers on authors books that complain about this issue. My problem with this complaint is that it goes against everything that readers learned in school. How many times did your teacher tell you, “Don’t ever judge a book by its cover”? Shame on you for shaming authors that were probably not in control of this process anyway…Although, this is humorous it doesn’t advance the field. Why? Those same authors/bloggers are not including books with really great covers. Therefore, the conversations go nowhere and we learn nothing…except that people are mean. I learned this in Kindergarten. Therefore, as a director would say, “Next!”

Self-proclaimed experts

The publishing industry is full of reviewers, authors, bloggers, book critics, publishers, and so on that worked for years in this industry. They have a formula for quality that includes many factors. Every genre is different in terms of who gets deemed as offering something quality to the industry. Indie authors, academic publishers, children’s publishers, and the vanity press market all have their different sets of rules. I love how the internet has created the self-proclaimed experts that have been in the industry less than a minute deciding who will make it in the industry. Isn’t that funny? I always thought it was the readers, marketing professionals, reviewers, and publishers that made those decisions. Why are these folks shaming others again?

I will end this blog with offering some sage advice for authors that have been in this industry for less than five years. As someone that has been in this industry for seven years, I urge authors at all levels to begin behaving like professionals. I started out doing research for three years on the publishing industry prior to initiating the publishing process. During that time, I researched the top twenty five publishing companies for my genre(s). My decision for my writing career has to do with me being knowledgeable about the industry and it dates back fifteen years. I knew that I would eventually want to publish other authors. Therefore, I am both traditionally and self-published. I found out that most people in the industry typically do both. You will find it difficult to find an author in the industry that doesn’t write under at least two pen names. I spent seven years writing prior to doing my three years of research. I wanted to ensure that had a certain number of titles. During my research, I read about authors being under pressure to produce work in a short amount of time. I had my work professionally edited and protected. I am now on my thirteenth book in seven years. I currently have eleven manuscripts on my desk of work that are ready to go. I also have three authors that I will publish in the next two years. It is so important to learn about this industry. I have been in it for a while now and I learn something different every day. I have great people in my network and a good circle of freelance professionals that can do everything. Do you know how to read your book contracts? Do you have a publicist? What is your marketing plan? How do you connect with your readers? Can you readily identify fans of your work? Are your readers waiting for your next book release? If you answered no to any of the previous questions, it is important that you spend time working on these things. I encourage authors to spend time learning the industry and less time shaming authors, readers, and publishers. It doesn’t make you a great author to do this type of thing. You look pathetic and thirsty at best. Please concentrate on creating really good books for readers. In the end, we should all be celebrating readers enjoying books period. This is why book shaming is a joke…right?

 
Recommended guides for new authors:
Sage Advice for the Indie Children’s Author by Tiffany A. Flowers

http://www.amazon.com/Sage-Advice-Indie-Childrens-Author-ebook/dp/B007O39XMW
 

The Not So Common Sense Guide for Authors by O. Keeys
 
http://www.amazon.com/Not-Common-Sense-Guide-Authors-ebook/dp/B007TLLOB2/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1391452950&sr=1-1&keywords=o.+keeys
 

      

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

 

Blogs About Publishing

Independent Publisher Links